Negative Ratings? (archived by John)

[BadAngel/Llama]

Okay, just remove the negative reputation then, that simple. I don't know why we have this system if we aren't allowed to use it. When I give someone positive/negative reputation, I'm not trying to act like a 'big man' or anything and definitely aren't laughing at someone with my friends who I give negative reputation, no, I just leave it at that. I think it's just a personal thing.

I give reputation based on how the person acts. I'm sorry if I acted wrong. I'm perfectly fine if someone wants to give me negative reputation, I don't assume that everyone likes me here. I wonder why this was brought up just now as members and others have been allowed to give negative reputation for ages already.

And I definitely aren't trying to impress anyone with giving negative reputation. I think it's a personal thing.

Just my opinion, don't want to offend anyone here.

[Destroyer]

Ok mayheM

[Destroy666]

I also agree with Spicy.

This system is for rating someone in good or bad way, depending on that person's behaviour, attitude, work in clan and ofc most likely own point of view (I like him or not). I can agree that we shoudln't rate negative own clanmates (can't see it happening), which makes bad atmosphere inside, but I see nothing wrong in doing it for bad behaving outsiders and ex-members.

Insulting? Humiliating? In what way? Because we give a red colored frame to their profile after they do worse things?

And no, I didn't laugh when I rated 2 people in negative way. Nor I didn't feel like a big man. But if you think I'm acting like 5 years old kid because of that - I have no further questions. Simple overreacting.

[MayheM]

Still see no need to make negative rates. For any reason. If you have a problem with someone, be a man or a woman and talk to them personally.

Wasn't pointing a finger at you Spicy directly anyway. But there still is no reason for anyone to give a negative rate. I am still waiting for a reasonable reply to that.

I am not talking about ex members who get mad or guests wanting to be funny. I am talking about members giving members bad rates.

How does that help or solve anything going on at this time in this clan most of us call a family?

All it does is cause retaliation and more fights. When does it end? Who decides to grow up first?

Scare did. He was the first one to realize that trying to fix a problem is more the mature way to deal with problems.

In my opinion this whole rate thing should be removed if people are gonna use it to intentionally hurt some one or in other cases punish someone.

It was fun in the first forum, but it sure isn't fun now. So if it's not gonna be used for fun then yea we can disable it.

Edited: I was writting while Destroy666 posted. I am indeed talking about current TWC members giving current TWC members bad ratings. I don't care about outsiders -_-

[Destroy666]

Oh ok, thought it's about Likwid who left and acted really bad lately so he got rated down by several people.

If it's only about members then agree with you. Fights inside clan should be avoided and in those cases the red frames aren't a way to solve them. They make it only worse. Already removed some negative reputations by members to members at beggining of this forum, which weren't really nice. And I hope they'll stop now too.

[Andre]

Still see no need to make negative rates. For any reason. If you have a problem with someone, be a man or a woman and talk to them personally.

why i cant say public if i dont like someone, why other need to care of it ?

Why take your cheap shot in forum. I know why, so that you can look like a big man and get a laugh with all your freinds. WOooo look what I did. I insulted a guy in forum and made him lose reputation. -_-

Don't look like a big person to me. It actually looks quite foolish. But hey, you got your shot at humiliating someone in forum wooooo bravooo.

you know what is foolish for me ?? this :

if you can't find it in you to remove the rate, then I ask that you leave this clan. That is not how a TWC member should act.

u are indirectly saying that if someone put a negative reputation and dont remove it, u kick him?

THIS IS FOOLISH mayhem



dont wont to be rude, but that is what i think.

[Spicy]

Still see no need to make negative rates. For any reason. If you have a problem with someone, be a man or a woman and talk to them personally.

Wasn't pointing a finger at you Spicy directly anyway. But there still is no reason for anyone to give a negative rate. I am still waiting for a reasonable reply to that.

If someone in my opinion deserves negative reputation I give it. In this case it was being inactive for ages then coming back and insulting people, flamebating and after leaving calling TWC clan and members by many insulting names. This in my opinion is good reason to give someone negative reputation. It's just that I thought that the person I rated negative didn't deserve to have a high reputation based how he acted.

Also assumed this was about Likwid as I asked if it was about Scare or Likwid and got no answer.

If it's about members I got to say that I agree mostly though I can understand it in some situations.

[Manzz]

Still see no need to make negative rates. For any reason. If you have a problem with someone, be a man or a woman and talk to them personally.

why i cant say public if i dont like someone, why other need to care of it ?

Why take your cheap shot in forum. I know why, so that you can look like a big man and get a laugh with all your freinds. WOooo look what I did. I insulted a guy in forum and made him lose reputation. -_-

Don't look like a big person to me. It actually looks quite foolish. But hey, you got your shot at humiliating someone in forum wooooo bravooo.

you know what is foolish for me ?? this :

if you can't find it in you to remove the rate, then I ask that you leave this clan. That is not how a TWC member should act.

u are indirectly saying that if someone put a negative reputation and dont remove it, u kick him?

THIS IS FOOLISH mayhem



dont wont to be rude, but that is what i think.

Why would you bring your personal problems in public? If there's fire between 2 members why would you bring it out in public and include even more people in the mess? This is gonna start a war..

The best way to solve problems is being a man and talking with the person you have problem with personally. It's much easier to solve problem with just 2 of you than a whole clan on each others neck.

You know about the situation in TWC and i don't find anything foolish about what mayhem wrote. If problems can't be solved face to face and someone has to bring the whole clan into the fight then it would be better for him to get the f*ck out of here.

[Andre]

How can a negative reputation bring a fight in the clan O.o

[Manzz]

How can a negative reputation bring a fight in the clan O.o

When you simply have problems with some guy and you will go to hes reputation and write what he has done to harm you so other players will see it. Someone else might feel touched about that too. For example when you rate someones friend with negative rating. They all get into this business that should have been solved face to face. And why the heck should anyone complain about someone with a negative rating so everyone can see. Why do the other people need to see it?

A lot of people seem to forget that although we are in internet there are real people behind the screens. If you have a problem in real life with someone, will you make a poster complaining about him/her to show it to the whole city?

How hard can it be to solve problems calmly like gentlemen in privacy. How can we call TWC clan a family if the members are doing this kind of sh*t to each other?